Is This What We Agreed To?
Introducing TrialCast Verified, a recovery audit of what your CRO billed against the contract you signed
This continues the series that began with "Building Something Worthy," on why biotech FP&A professionals deserve better than the tools they have.
Every month-end, a batch of CRO invoices lands in my inbox. I code them and book the accrual on top of them, because I am the finance function at my clients. And most months there's at least one line where I stop and ask: is this what we agreed to?
In the first piece in this series, I listed 66 recurring tasks in the FP&A cycle at a clinical-stage biotech. Reconciling invoices against contracts was one of them. It's also the easiest one to do halfway: check the total against the budget, check the math, approve. Doing it properly means tying each line back to the right version of the contract, through every change order, and there's never a week when that's the most urgent thing on the list.
The question I keep coming back to isn't whether finance teams review CRO invoices. They do, every month. It's whether anyone has the time to read them against the contract, line by line. That's a different job and a much harder one.
That job is now TrialCast Verified, and it starts today.
Why CRO billing drifts
I want to be fair to CROs here, because this isn't a story about bad actors. Running a global trial is enormously complex, and the people doing it are mostly doing it well. But three things about the arrangement make drift almost inevitable.
The work changes, and the billing has to keep up. A 2016 study by the Tufts Center for the Study of Drug Development, published in Therapeutic Innovation & Regulatory Science, found that 57% of protocols have at least one substantial amendment, at a median direct cost of $535k in Phase III. Each amendment usually means a CRO change order. Every change order is a new set of prices, units and dates layered on the old ones. The more layers, the easier it is for a line to keep billing at a rate that no longer applies, or past a service that has ended.
The vendor that bills is also the source of the numbers. Units delivered, sites active, visits completed: most of it comes from the CRO's own reports. That's nobody's fault; it's how the arrangement works. It just means the invoice and the evidence for it usually come from the same place. Trust, but verify.
The check is too detailed to do by hand. Tying every invoice line back to the right version of the contract, through every change order, across a few years of billing, is days of work that few finance teams can spare. I know, because month-end doesn't wait. (The accrual still has to be booked, and it's only as good as the invoices and vendor-provided estimates underneath it.)
The result is money paid that was never owed, and an accrual that's harder to defend at year end than it should be.
What TrialCast Verified does
TrialCast Verified comes from the same place as TrialCast®, our trial financial platform: TrialCast models what a trial should cost, and Verified checks what it was actually billed. TrialCast Verified is a recovery audit of what your CRO billed against the contract you signed. It finds billing that doesn't match, documents it, and drafts the credit request for you to send.
You share the contract, the change orders, the invoices, the site budgets and the visit export from your EDC (coded subject IDs and visit dates only, never names or other personal identifiers). We rebuild what should have been billed. AI checks every line against the contract. Then a person signs off: I review every audit myself, and nothing reaches you without a named reviewer standing behind it.
Every charge comes back as one of three things: credit due (billed beyond the contract, with the credit request drafted for you), needs backup (a document or the CRO's records will settle it), or matches the contract (nothing to do).
- Your documents in Contract, invoices, site budgets, EDC export
- Every line checked against the contract AI checks. A person signs off.
- A credit request out Drafted for you to send in your own name
Every charge comes back as one of three things
- Credit due Billed beyond the contract
- Needs backup A document or the CRO's records will settle it
- Matches the contract Nothing to do
Who it's for
Any sponsor with a CRO-run trial under way or in close-out, at least 12 months of CRO invoices, and the documents: the contract and change orders, the invoices, the site budgets and the EDC export. The trial needs to be running or in close-out, because credits come off invoices that are still open, and a year of billing gives enough to test against the contract.
How you start
Small, and with every decision staying yours.
- A one-page preview. If your trial qualifies, we sign an NDA, you send the CRO contract, change orders and invoices, and we send back one page showing whether a full audit is worth it. No cost, and no commitment beyond sending the documents.
- The full audit. If you want to proceed to the full audit and recovery, you add the site budgets and the EDC export, and we test everything.
- Help with the request. We draft the credit request with the contract clause and the invoice line behind each item. You send it in your own name, and you decide whether and when. We never contact your CRO.
What it costs
Nothing to start. Our fee is a share of what we recover, paid only when money actually comes back to you. If we recover nothing, you pay nothing. "Recovered" means credits applied against your invoices, refunds received, or invoice reductions taken, not credits promised.
That structure is deliberate. A recovery audit should only cost you money when it has already made you money.
What it isn't
It isn't an audit opinion, and we aren't a CPA firm. It's a recovery audit and reconciliation: billing that doesn't match the contract, found and documented. It isn't legal advice. And it isn't a fight with your CRO. Every item is evidenced against the contract they signed, which is the strongest footing a credit request can have.
Your data stays under your NDA and in your own system; if you don't have one, we provide a dedicated folder for you alone. The AI we use is barred by contract from training on it, nothing is shared with any other client, and everything is returned or deleted at the end, your way.
Why I built it
Most of the answers to month-end's hardest billing questions are already in the contract. They just haven't been read against the invoices yet, because nobody has the week it takes.
TrialCast Verified is that reading, done for every line of every invoice, by someone who has booked the accrual on top of them.
If you have a CRO-run trial under way and this resonates with your experience, I'd welcome the conversation: caladan.ai/verified
Holly Lujan
COO & CFO, Co-Founder at CaladanAI™
Holly is a biotech finance executive with 15 years of experience in FP&A for clinical-stage pharmaceutical and biotech companies. She is the co-founder, COO and CFO of CaladanAI, where she and her co-founder are building the financial operating system for clinical-stage biotech.
Learn about TrialCast Verified